Where to go - Ibiza or Malia?

Me and 3 friends have decided on a last minute holiday at the end of august, and are now having dramas about where to go. We originally said Ibiza and then another friend said it might be a bit too "" for us...we're a bunch of girls that enjoy clubbing as well as lazing by the beach all day - but are more into cheesy/pop stuff then dance music - which is apparently all they play in Ibiza. Please help!